Pat Leonard’s NFL Notes: Will optics govern final Deshaun Watson ruling? Or will NFL get its unprecedented ban?

Roger Goodell’s appointee in the Deshaun Watson appeal, former N.J. attorney general Peter Harvey, could drop the hammer of an indefinite suspension plus a major fine on the Cleveland Browns quarterback this week.

Or Harvey could marginally increase Watson’s six-game suspension, handed down by neutral judge Susan Robinson, and reveal this process to be more of a negotiated compromise than the league and union have portrayed it to be.

Miami-based attorney Brad Sohn, who has litigated several cases covering football’s collective bargaining agreement, thinks it will be the latter: something like 8-to-10 games plus a huge fine.

“I view this situation as a case study in optics,” Sohn told the Daily News Saturday morning.

Essentially, from a legal perspective, while Watson’s alleged behavior warrants punishment, imposing an indefinite suspension on a league appeal could be perceived as Goodell delivering a forceful rebuke of Robinson and, therefore, of this entire new collectively bargained arrangement with the union in the personal conduct policy.

Goodell already appointed Harvey to hear the league’s appeal, rather than serving as the final judge and jury himself, which the CBA grants him the right to do.

The NFL has made no secret that is still pushing for an indefinite suspension, plus a monetary fine and mandatory treatment. But the appointments of Robinson (jointly by the NFL and NFLPA) and Harvey (by the league) give both the NFL and union distance from the final decision.

So a middle ground — building on Watson-league negotiations that stalled prior to Robinson’s ruling — would allow both the NFL and NFLPA to walk away claiming the process worked.

“Doing that — essentially brokering a deal through the public display of an arms’ length process with different people assisting to broker the discipline — makes the NFLPA look good because it can say the new CBA works,” …read more

Source:: The Denver Post

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.